Kentucky Football: National Signing Day Wrap-Up
I was reminded today of a conversation several years ago with a younger partner at the large law firm where I used to work. As a lowly associate, I wondered why there was palpable angst among a group of people who all made such a good living. I've never forgotten his response. "If all I knew was what I made, I'd be very happy with it. But I have the curse of knowing what everyone else makes too." As I later learned myself, the fact that you are on a great totem pole isn't necessarily comforting when you are at the bottom.
That pretty much encapsulates my feeling on National Signing Day. First off, the Cats had a great day today, with things breaking about as well as could be expected. Kentucky held on to everyone it had locked down and pulled a couple of last minute coups. Joker and his staff did an excellent job this offseason, especially considering that the season didn't go as we'd all hoped. Still, this year's class puts us once again at or near the bottom of the SEC.
First, lets take a look at how things unfolded. Last night ESPN reported, and today it was confirmed, that Pratville, AL QB Jalen Whitlow would change his commitment from Arkansas State to the Cats. As expected, Ft. Thomas Highlands QB Patrick Towles signed on the dotted line. In fact, his was the first LOI Joker received this morning. In fact, all in state players who'd previously committed, including big DT Thomas Chapman from Louisville Manual, followed suit. Things got even better as the morning continued.
The late signee Kentucky most coveted, LB Khalid Henderson from Austell, Ga picked the Cats over Ole Miss this morning. Henderson was rated four stars by Scout, and for reasons hard to divine, was cast aside by Tennessee in January. Likewise, Kentucky landed Atlanta RB Justin Taylor, who recently reopened his recruiting after being asked to greyshirt by Alabama. With no defections, Kentucky was able to round out its class and get a full compliment of 25 signees by adding Sterling Wright, a DB from Charlotte who signed committed to Jacksonville State in 2011 before deciding to spend a year in prep school.
Twins Daron and Zach Blalock (Mookie's kids) who I saw during Pigskinapalooza 2011 remained committed and signed on as well. This was key for more reasons than just my vested interest of having travelled to see them. Zach had a monster senior year, and was on the radar of a number of higher profile teams. Ultimately, the vultures did not have their day. Truth be told, it was that kind of day for Kentucky. Certainly something to feel good about.
Of course, college recruiting being the phenomena that it is, and this being the Internet age, everyone and their brother has now had a say in how the Wildcats class stacked up. When viewed through the prism of the entire SEC, the picture becomes less flattering. Kentucky got the highest marks from Scout, who anointed the class #31 in the nation. Of course, #31 overall was only good for eleventh best in the conference. Other assessments were worse. Rivals puts us outside the Top 50, and dead last in the SEC. Likewise, 247 ranked the class 53rd, which again left us wearing the SEC collar.
Other than making snails taste delicious and kissing infinitely more fun, the French haven't done much for me. But there is a French saying I really dig. It is plus ca change, plus c'est la meme chose. Translated, "the more that things change, the more they stay the same." It's hard not to feel that way when looking at these rankings. My advice, though, is don't get too caught up in it. While this class isn't transcendent, it is competitive. Given the year we had, filling a class with three star players and picking up some key pieces late in the game is all we could ask from this coaching staff.
24 comments
|
2 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I like the class,
and hopefully, if the Cats are able to field a winning team next season, this is something for Joker and staff to build on.
The Taylor kid will be UK’s first look at a bruising back in quite some time (Artose Pinner was the last WIldcat back with Taylor’s power game that I can remember), and in my mind was a terrific late edition. Plus, needs were filled on the line and secondary, spots UK had to fill.
Thanks for the update, Alex!
Somewhat less than an exact science...
since Scouts ranks Florida State as the #10 class and 247 has them as #2, and this is not atypical. But what I note is that there are a bunch of schools who take their football seriously that are ranked below us on the board. On the Scouts board which gives us our highest rating that includes Missouri and Vanderbilt, and UofL, along with folks like Nebraska, Penn State, Boise State, & Michigan State.
And if we were comparing BB recruiting, and a team who had been struggling came up with such a recruiting class, would we condemn the effort because it didn’t measure up to who Cal gets signed for UK, or who coach K gets lined up, or any of the perennial powers? I don’t think we would expect such a miracle but we would watch and see how the staff developed the talent they got, knowing that success of the program would only make the process a bit easier in each following year. And I think it obvious we did “steal” a couple of guys from the big boys, if what I read is true.
and encouraging day all in all, but it doesn’t put us on a par with "Bama or LSU, but that just means we will have to work harder at it. As a Cat fan from the 60’s, and living far away, it seems somewhat strange to think football is that important, but I welcome the chance to cheer a winning team in football, something I never got to do when I lived in Lexington.
Scout
Scout is using up it’s credability fast, they completely screwed the rankings from almost every kid in the south placing a higher emphasis on the west coast and the new england area, also the disproportionately rate a class higher the more prospects there are in a class. i would stick with espn, 247, and rivals guys they are more consistent and relaible than scout
but addressing UK’s class this is really good for us not the best we have ever brought in but a very solid class were we had to take more prospects on both the O-line and on the D-line who are consistantly underrated compared to their counterpart skill men. The reason being it harder for people to predict how a high schooler will grow and fit into a D-1 lineman while its pretty easy to see how a shifty skill back could translate.
I like using class size as a factor
Considering how bad all the scouting services are at picking out which 3 stars will turn out to be good players, having a greater pool of them should be considered a good thing. For instance, I would rather have UK’s class than Mississippi’s despite Ole Miss having 2 more 4 stars (according to ESPN). They only signed 18 players. I’d much rather have two 4 stars and fifteen 3 stars than four 4 stars and five three stars. A bad football team needs to cast a wider net than that in order to rebuild. Yet 247 and Rivals rank Ole Miss ahead of UK.
Class size is a factor
however it should not be the largest factor it should be the quality of the players vs. the number of spots that are available on the team b/c with only 85 scholarships not everyone will make it on the team. I think we did a great job with who we got this year and i think Towles was ranked crimanally low hes and elite 11 qb for godsakes picked by a superbowl winning qb. That said its harder for the services to pick out which linemen will be good which is why their are less of them ranked higher per captia than the skill positions
I'm a big fan of 24/7 Sports myself
Got a bunch of the top football guys, and has a great interface.
Thanks for the update Alex.
I like to live by this quote, “Years wrinkle the skin, but to give up enthusiasm wrinkles the soul.” I can stop those wrinkles from happening. I Believe!
Blue... there is no other color to Bleed !!!
Wrapped up neatly and tied up with a bow.
Great job, Alex.
I was excited to hang on to the twins, and anytime you steal one from Alabama with Nick Saban at the helm, you have to feel good about that. If I didn’t know anything else about him other than Nick Saban signed him to a scholarship, it would be enough.
Also, it’s much more difficult to effectively evaluate football players than it is basketball due to their sheer numbers. Anything below a 5* in football is almost a crap shoot, and can go either way. 150 players are about the limit of these services’ ability to effectively evaluate, and after that, you just have to trust that the staff saw what they wanted.
A Sea of Blue -- Kentucky Sports for the Discerning Fan
I entirely agree with your point on recruiting evaluations
Added on top of the sheer numbers is the fact that there are no high school/AAU tournaments in football. The percentage of 3 stars that the analysts have actually seen play is miniscule. Football recruit actually play so infrequently that it’s logistically impossible. You just have to trust the staff, which I do.
Glen great job on keeping everyone informed
but i have to disagree with u on the crapshoot thing below a 5*. here’s a link to a stats study done on recruiting rankings and why they matter in football
http://rivals.yahoo.com/ncaa/football/blog/dr_saturday/post/Mister-Relevant-Why-you-shouldn-t-dismiss-recru?urn=ncaaf,216887#remaining-content
I think that actually does more to support my argument than refute it, on balance.
A Sea of Blue -- Kentucky Sports for the Discerning Fan
If you need more,
UKAthletics put together a nice little video package.
Blue... there is no other color to Bleed !!!
I don't follow football
but I remember Mookie Blalock. Cool that we got his kids here at UK, even if it’s in a different sport.
I too fondly remember his largely mediocre Hawks teams of the 90's
Coach Lenny Wilkens! Dikembe Mutombo and Steve Smith! I shall commence with a commemorative finger wag.
Wow
No idea the twins were Mookie’s kids. I used to love playing as Blalock and Stacey Augmon in NBA Jam.
Nice job on this Alex,
after looking the whole class over, a #31 ranking is nothing to be ashamed of, even though some rank this class last in the SEC, I guess even being last in the SEC is better than being really good somewhere else. I know that a couple of these kids stuck out, and assuming everything is status quo, I am thinking that most of these guys are looking to be at least a year getting into the starting lineup, but are there any of them that could be real impact players right away? Possibly Henderson, Taylor, or Wright?
I am now and shall forever be the Cat in The Hat, The Artist Formerly Known As ABC!!!
by Greg Alan Edwards on Feb 2, 2012 1:00 PM EST reply actions
Good question
My money is on Henderson, because LB will be a lot thinner than some of our other positions. No idea where Taylor will end up on the depth chart. That seems to be a crapshoot a lot of the time. Even though we are relatively solid at DT, I could see Thomas Chapman getting into the rotation. With all the DBs we recruited, you’d have to think that at least one makes an impact. Of course, if Towles can actually compete for the starting QB job, he shoots right to the top of the list.
ALS
by Alex Scutchfield on Feb 2, 2012 1:26 PM EST up reply actions
I don't know much
but I know UK lost both corners. I’d bet some of the CBs get on the field. If he’s fully healthy, I bet Taylor gets time. UK doesn’t have another big back. Short yardage situations could become his.
I was thinking Taylor could really help us situationally if he's healthy.
You’re right, he has great size.
A Sea of Blue -- Kentucky Sports for the Discerning Fan
Nothing is more frustrating than failed short yardage conversions.
I hope Taylor makes them a rare occurrence over the next 4 years.
Other than Towles, I agree.
On tape this kid looks great. He’s up to speed in three steps, runs North-South and I don’t think I’ve seen a player run with such small steps – it gives him tremendous power.
War is God's way of teaching Americans geography. - Ambrose Bierce










