A Sea Of Blue: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Race to the BCS: rankings, in-game scores & blogs Bar-right-arrows



Billy Gillispie: A SWOT Analysis

Marc Maggard at Kentucky Ink [free registration required] recently posted an insightful article looking at the fact that Gillispie hasn't landed any big men for UK yet.  I propose to take that a bit further and do what we call a SWOT (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats) analysis in business (and elsewhere).  If you have ever done, or are thinking about doing a business plan, a SWOT analysis is generally considered to be an important part.

This analysis will be performed with regard only to his merits as a basketball coach with emphasis on recruiting, not as a human being.  So let's SWOT young William, shall we?

Strengths


  • Tireless recruiter -- Gillispie has a reputation as a recruiter since his days as a Bill Self assistant.  He has successfully recruited players to Illinois and TAMU.

  • Unrelenting worker -- Gillispie famously wound up in a divorce because of a "lack of work-life balance".

  • Success at every level below professional -- Gillispie has been successful at every level of basketball, other than the pros, where he has never coached.  Gillispie has proven that he knows what it takes to succeed.

  • In his dream job -- Many of his peers are happy to be where they are, but have one eye open for better opportunities.  Not Gillispie, at least not yet.  He is apparently exactly where he wants to be, and is very glad to be here.  That will positively impact the zeal with which he attacks the job.

  • Relative youth -- Gillispie is younger than most, and as a rising coach has yet to reach the pinnacle of his profession.  He is therefore hungry for more success

  • Powerful program -- To use a automotive metaphor, Gillispie has just traded in a Mustang for a Maserati.  Placing such power in the hands of a relentless, determined man is a strong positive.

Weaknesses


  • Out of his depth -- Taking the automotive metaphor further, he has the keys to a Maserati, but can he keep it between the yellow lines without getting a ticket?  He has never coached a legendary program like Kentucky, and TAMU is a very large step down in terms of basketball programs.  Is it too large a step?

  • No Association experience -- this is a big negative in today's college ranks.  Blue chip recruits see only one thing at the end of their rainbow -- a first-round draft pick.  The coach they believe can get them there the soonest will have an advantage, and Gillispie has no discernible track record of doing so.

  • New coach, new school -- Recruits will be less comfortable with him until he is a proven commodity in the big-time coaching ranks.  He also has done almost no relationship-building as UK coach due to his short time on the job.  This is only a temporary weakness.

  • Personality and presentation -- Gillispie isn't as polished as some of his peers.  That won't hurt him much with the recruits themselves, but the families will often be more impressed with smooth talkers like Pitino, Donovan and Calipari.  Sometimes Gillispie's plain-spoken country-boy style will be an advantage, particularly in the South and Southwest.  Not so much everywhere else.

  • Organizational Skills -- The fact that he has not yet filled out his coaching staff calls Gillispie's organizational skills into question with me.  It may be that he doesn't consider it critical, but if so, I think we can make an argument that he is mistaken.

  • Zeal -- Alacrity and diligence would seem to be more of an advantage than a disadvantage, but until he settles into the job, it is going to be questioned as desperation as much as passion.  This is only temporary, however.  After a year or two, this will move over to the strength section.

Opportunities


  • National presence -- TAMU is more of a regional presence than a national one.  Illinois would be considered a national presence, but Gillispie was only an assistant there.  With Kentucky, his reach is truly national, but he still tends to recruit regionally.  The opportunity for a broader reach exists.

  • Contrast with past staff -- Gillispie is truly as different from Tubby Smith as it is possible to be in terms of style, personality and focus.  Other schools will be forced to adapt to his methods, placing them at a disadvantage compared to previous.  This is a temporary opportunity.

  • New facilities -- The fact of our just-constructed Craft center gives Gillispie the opportunity to use it as an advantage to lure recruits, but other schools will soon follow suit.  This opportunity is only short to medium term.

  • Powerful fan base -- Recruiting opportunities such as Big Blue Madness can become even more extraordinary with the fan support he will enjoy as the new UK coach.  This support needs constant success to feed it, so he must take early advantage of this opportunity to keep it available in succeeding years.

  • Technology -- Gillispie has proven, through the use of text messages, to be willing to utilize technology in a way Smith never was.  The texting has been taken away by the NCAA, so he must find other ways to leverage technology in recruiting.

  • Lack of distractions -- Whatever the merits of family life, Gillispie has none.  Therefore, he has fewer familial distractions than almost any other coach of an elite basketball program.  Logically, that cannot be assumed to last forever, so Gillispie must exploit the opportunity early, before it gets subsumed into life.

  • Strong athletic department support -- Right now, Gillispie has the total, unqualified support of the AD and the department.  The tendency will be for that to change negatively over time, as unqualified support is a rare and transitory thing.  He must leverage that to his advantage while it lasts.

Threats


  • Outside distractions -- A UK coach has many demands on his time from inside and outside the program.  Managing these distractions will be critical.

  • Burnout -- Gillispie is known to be tireless, but no human being can keep up that kind of pace without paying a price, either in mental or physical health.  Gillispie must manage his passion for success and find a better life balance, or the frailties of the human condition will impair his success.

  • Other coaches -- Peers are feeling the pressure of Gillispie's relentless effort, and they will respond.  That response will unquestionably be an attack through the SEC and NCAA as well as dissimulation by coaching staffs to recruits and others.  His lack of player NBA success will be lampooned to  recruits.  Every action will be scrutinized by peers for NCAA compliance.  His "style" will be attacked as plodding or slow, the opposite of the NBA run-and-shoot, selfish style that is all the rage among todays young prospects.

  • The NCAA -- Kentucky has long been known as a serial NCAA violator.  The fact that we have kept our noses clean during the Tubby Smith era is a wonderful thing, but the NCAA, as it must with every new coach at a high-profile school, will be carefully scrutinizing Gillispie.  Gillispie must stay clean.

  • The Kentucky fans -- Kentucky fans demand success, sometimes to the point of detriment to their own program.  Gillispie must be aware of fan passion, and take an active role in managing it.  If the fans turn on him, his odds of success decrease dramatically.  Fan criticism at UK is a force of nature, and can destroy a coach's ability to manage the perception of his program.

  • The media -- The sports media have fawned over Gillispie since the reality of Smith's departure subsided, but this is temporary.  They will turn on him again as soon as they have a reason.  He must manage the media better than his predecessor, or face a difficult and stormy relationship with them that will distract him from his job.

So there you have it -- my stab at a SWOT analysis of Billy Gillispie at UK.  This will obviously change as time goes on, but it will be interesting to look back later and see how it worked out.

0 recs | Comment 16 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

room for improvement
i don't think anyone can argue that in his short time here, coach gillispie has done a phenomenal job so far.

i think what i liked best, what makes me so optimistic about the future is that the weaknesses listed are either temporary or can be improved relatively easily. well, other than the association experience, though one could argue that's temporary as well. the longer he's here, the more blue chippers he gets, the more first round picks will be produced.

the only thing that worries me is burnout. i'm not how long someone can go at the speed he's always at. and it's one thing at TAMU, but a whole other animal here at UK. everything's magnified and there isn't another college job in the country that has as much pressure to succeed.

GO BIG BLUE!! GO BIG BLUE!!

by UKWildCatFanatic on Aug 7, 2007 11:26 AM EDT   0 recs

"organizational skills"
while his organizational skills are cited here as a negative, i think a pretty good argument can be made that, insofar as his apparent failure to complete his staff yet is concerned, this isn't a problem at all.

here's why - there's a good possibility that the only reason that he hasn't officially named a 3rd assistant (or director of b-ball ops) yet is that, as soon as the hire is officially made, the assistant in question will be bound by ncaa rules, and all the limitations and restrictions inherent thereto.

i spoke with larry vaught a couple weeks ago, and he told me that rashown mcleod was in fact going to be named the director of basketball operations at uk, and when i asked him why this hasn't been made official yet, he said that as long as mcleod is technically unemployed, he can pretty much do what he wants to do, and isn't hamstrung by all the ncaa rules and regulations that he'd be bound by if he were a member of the staff.

just speculation on my part, but this could very well be the reason that a 3rd assistant has yet to be named, and if that's the case, then it belongs on the "strengths" list, under the heading "shrewd program manger."

by wwh mustaine on Aug 7, 2007 11:43 AM EDT   0 recs

I expected ...
to have some people disagree on this point, and it is certainly far from a fact.  I simply think it would have been in Gillispie's best interests to get his staff in place sooner, but an argument could be made to the contrary.

by Truzenzuzex on Aug 7, 2007 2:02 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Another way of saying it
Strength - BCG is truly "plugged in" like few others at the grassroots level of recruiting....perhaps not in every corner of the country but still hard wired because he has been to all these venues countless times over the past several years...and he's not that far removed from being a full time assistant....he has so much more knowledge and insight than most, he has seen more and contacted more......everyone shows at the premeire camps but BCG is seemingly everywhere

Threat - "The Job" - only a handful of people really understand the unique pressures of this job.....some handle it well and others, well.....only time will tell how BCG does

Unknowns - The staff as recruiters - we all know that staff recruiters can make or break a coach - Denny Crum never fully recovered from the loss of Wade Houston.....Pitino's UK staff overdelivered....Tubby's staff underdelivered....this bunch is highly thought of but they must bring home on the bacon...the head guy can't do it all

On another note, I ran into a far western KY fan (they are all Cats there) this past weekend.  When I asked him what they thought of BCG, he had an interesting take.  "I didn't know much about him because I don't pay attention to any basketball in TX but I guess he's okay.  He'll be fine......as long as he wins.....alot."

by run and gun on Aug 7, 2007 1:11 PM EDT   0 recs

Western Ky Fans....
They ARE all Cats over there; we run 'em out if they ain't.

That's my redNECK of the woods.

by blueblood on Aug 7, 2007 7:17 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Totally Agree

I grew up in far, far, Western Ky and get back there a couple times a year.......to a part of the state that most other regions of KY know very little about....as evidenced by the average person's geographic view that the western end of the state ends at Owensboro or that WKU is truly western KY.  But I digress.......perhaps I'll write a diary about this interesting collection of "unknown" fans......they live and die with every possession, the economy dips and booms with every game........perhaps even more so than in Lexington and Hazard...they know their Cats though few have ever had the opportunity to be inside Rupp arena....and, they all still consider UL to be the Evil Empire

by run and gun on Aug 7, 2007 7:30 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Typo
The above "Subject" should read blue blood. Not gobblgook.

by Ken Howlett on Aug 7, 2007 9:06 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Analysis of the Analysis
Strengths- I feel Tru has accuarately portrayed BCG's strengths.

Weakenesses-"Out of his depth": I would characterize this as an unknown, rather than a weakness. The fact that he understands where he is, that he "gets" it, might tilt this alleged weakness to a positive.
"No associaton experience": I agree with this assessment, BUT, how Acie Law performs could change this perception.
"Personality and presentation": Attempting to judge how a particular family will respond to his pesonality traits is nearly impossible, in my view. The most important component of recruiting is sincerity. If the families, and players believe what he says, I believe it is inconsequential how he says it.
"Organizational skills": Generally Type A, Alpha Male personalities are very organized when it comes to business. Not having hired a third assistant is puzzling to me though. I have read stories attempting to explain away this void in the staff, (Mr. Mustaine , above, references his converstation with Larry Vaught), but I have decided to take a wait and see stance on this issue.(As if BCG cares what stance I take)
"Zeal": In my opinion desperation left the building when he signed Patterson, Legion, and Liggons.

Opportunities-"Lack of distractions":Keep the women away from this man!

Threats- I agree totally with Tru's statements regarding this area.

Great post, as usual, by Tru.

Let me note that this posting is only my opinion, I am not discounting anything Tru wrote. Many of the areas touched on are very subjective. It will be interesting, and I am sure rewarding, to see how the tenure of BCG plays out.

by Ken Howlett on Aug 7, 2007 2:06 PM EDT   0 recs

Fair enough ...
I'm always glad to have different points of view, and yours make as much sense as mine.

by Truzenzuzex on Aug 7, 2007 3:58 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Re: Tru
It's too bad we can't turn our sense into cents.

by Ken Howlett on Aug 7, 2007 4:49 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

G
According to G himself he has a reason for not filling out his staff yet. He had to wait for the end of the nba season to fill out the third position  . Unfortunately whoever he was looking at got a job in the league. I find two positives in his attempt to hire someone with connection with the league.
1) I helps take care of that lack of experience in professional ball and two it demonstrates that he obviously had a reason for waiting. If the job isnt filled yet it's because G wants it that way for now.

Dont forget Deron Williams when thinking about Acie Law. I know G was only an assistant at Illinois but players know the point guards who he has coached and they all have good things to say about him. I think this is part of the reason about a billion point guards are considering UK and we are having problems landing a big man for 08. Once G has demonstrated his playing style at UK for a couple seasons I dont anticipate any problems landing big men.  

DEEETROIT BASKETBALLL!!!

by davw83 on Aug 7, 2007 2:55 PM EDT   0 recs

Re: davw83
Excellent points.

by Ken Howlett on Aug 7, 2007 3:54 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Sense
If we could turn our sense into cents those at ASOB  would be the richest fans in the BBN.  
DEEETROIT BASKETBALLL!!!

by davw83 on Aug 7, 2007 7:32 PM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

An exciting user-driven SBNation blog, by and for fans of the Kentucky Wildcats.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Me_small
Legion coming back??
Small
A Favor To Ask (For Erik Daniels' Mom)
Bball0_small
Patterson now projected as a lottery pick
Small
Looking for Game Film from 1986-1987
Small
Where have all the "players" gone?
Small
Looking toward January . . . a change in the lineup Part II
Dj_small
UK vs. U of L/Momentum Shifter
Small
Turnover Improvement: Real or Mirage?
Small
Dan Issel Was Not UK's First Choice In 1966
Img_1595_small
Opinions on whether Slone might transfer

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managing Editor

Tru_small Truzenzuzex

Editor

Small Ken Howlett

ad

Site Meter