A Sea Of Blue: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Cal RB Jahvid Best Seriously Injured, Carted Off Field

Wonder where it comes from?

The UK fanbase has been saddled in recent years with the tag of being "too harsh" and for having "unreal expectations." Many in the national media in particular seem flabbergasted by the way Big Blue Nation can see a win as a loss.

Ever wonder where that kind of attitude stems from? Look no further than the local "coverage" of the game.

Much-maligned beat writer Jerry Tipton (whom I profiled a year ago) from the Herald-Leader decided not only his lede graph, but his headline ("Cats struggle in win") would really get to the heart of a game in which the lineup changed, four starters scored most of the points and UK won by 15:

LOUISVILLE - Joe Crawford and Ramel Bradley hit clutch three-pointers. ... Almost as sad as the attendance, Kentucky needed the shots to hold off Chattanooga 79-63 Tuesday night.

Now that's the way you tell it. Start with two negatives and work your way backwards! He goes on to focus on the attendance several more times. I'm surprised he wasn't able to work some mention in there about the hot dogs in the writer's pregame area being "too mushy" or something.

Seriously. What is the hope of covering the Wildcats, only to find all the things they didn't do right? The not-so-subtle jab at the attendance is clearly trying to imply that the program isn't jibing with the fans. If Tipton has something to say, maybe he should just say it instead of pretending he's objectively covering the team. Doesn't the LHL already have some "columnists" (if you can stomach them)?

Contrast Tipton's whine-fest with Brett Dawson's view from the Courier-Journal:

Ramel Bradley didn't need to watch the game film, study tape or look at stat sheets to see what he could feel. ... The University of Kentucky guard hadn't been himself lately, he said last night after the Wildcats' 79-63 win against Chattanooga. ... "I wasn't being aggressive," said Bradley, who corrected that problem with a career-best 23 points as UK won in front of 11,641 fans at Freedom Hall. "Sometimes it felt like I wasn't even out on the court."

The story is now set. The basics passed along (attendance, minus the commentary, and score), Dawson gets into his topic via a quote from a player. Tipton, on the other hand, could have just as easily written his story without any comments from the player, since he established from line 1 what his tone and purpose in writing was.

Now tell me which of these writers has been inducted into the Basketball Writers Hall of Fame? (Hint: it's not the good one.)

0 recs  |  Comment 2 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

As a journalism student...
I'd say that's not nearly as bad a lead as you think it is.  When a UK men's basketball game can't outdraw a UK-UofL women's game, that's a pretty big fact.

Is Tipton's piece an example of good sportswriting?  Not really, but Dawson's piece isn't much better.

by Quietude on Dec 6, 2006 11:00 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Purpose
I disagree. Tipton's point in writing is to cover the game, not cast judgment on the size of the crowd or on the relationship between a women's game and this one.

If he was writing a column, I might understand. But this pseudo-reportage is endemic to the sports world, and it stinks.

The Online home of Big Blue Nation ...

by JL Blue on Dec 7, 2006 9:31 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

An exciting community-driven SBNation blog, by and for fans of the Kentucky Wildcats.

Community Guidelines
[UPDATED 3/31/2009]
Start posting about the Wildcats »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Harold-the-dog_small
We look into our crystal balls
128_small
2009 SEC Football Schedule
Miners__2__small
Inconsistency plagues Kentucky football
Iconator_2f99b654c1a51345314f8a8458af10e5_small
Best Programs 2000-2009
Small
Excuses and Analysis of The Campbellsville Game
Small
I need tickets for Friday
Photo_small
Gillespie changes plea
128_small
Pure Defensive and Offensive Efficiency
Small
Tipton Mans Up To Another Error
Uk_logo_blue_small
A Long Hard Look Ahead....

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Twitter Widget -- Follow me!


Managing Editor

Tru_small Truzenzuzex

Editor

Small Ken Howlett

Author

Diane-black_heels_small BigSkyCat

Official Partner of CBS Sports